Gentle Parenting Criticism from Family: My Mother-in-Law Said I’m Too Soft – Am I Ruining My Kids?

“Beta, you’re making him weak. In our time, children listened to elders without question. This gentle parenting nonsense will spoil him completely.”

These words from my mother-in-law hit me like a truck last Tuesday evening. Here I was, dealing with gentle parenting criticism from the person whose opinion mattered most to my husband. As I watched my 4-year-old son Arjun have what I call a “big feeling moment,” I found myself questioning everything about my respectful parenting approach.

Instead of shouting or threatening him, I had knelt down to his level and said, “I can see you’re really upset about turning off the TV. That’s hard, isn’t it?” But my mother-in-law’s parenting advice was clear: I was being too soft, and this would ruin my child.

Am I too soft with my kids gentle parenting approach? This question haunted me for weeks after that incident.

When Gentle Parenting Criticism Shakes Your Parenting Confidence

I’d been practicing gentle parenting techniques for two years. I read every book, followed the Instagram accounts, and truly believed in treating my children with respect while setting firm boundaries. But sitting there with my son still crying and facing gentle parenting criticism from family, my parenting confidence crumbled completely.

The traditional vs modern parenting debate suddenly felt very personal. My mother-in-law had raised an amazing son – my husband turned out wonderful. So maybe her mother-in-law parenting advice held more weight than all my research on gentle parenting techniques?

That night, I found myself desperately googling:

• “Am I too soft with my kids gentle parenting?”
• “Gentle parenting criticism – is it valid?”
• “Traditional vs modern parenting – which works better?”

The parenting self-doubt was consuming me.

The Breaking Point: When Gentle Parenting Criticism Gets Personal

The next morning brought the real test of my resolve. Arjun didn’t want to get dressed for preschool. Usually, my gentle parenting techniques involved giving choices: “Would you like to put on your shirt first or your pants first?”

But with my mother-in-law watching and her gentle parenting criticism fresh in my mind, I felt pressure to follow her mother-in-law parenting advice.

“Arjun, get dressed NOW,” I snapped, abandoning my respectful parenting approach.

He looked confused – this wasn’t his mama’s usual tone. The confusion turned to tears, and soon he was having a full meltdown. My mother-in-law jumped in with traditional vs modern parenting tactics: “Stop crying or no cartoon time for a week!”

The crying got worse. I stood there realizing that neither the harsh approach nor my supposedly “soft” gentle parenting techniques seemed to be working under this gentle parenting criticism.

Related read: Gentle Parenting Examples from My Real-Life Journey

Rebuilding Parenting Confidence Despite Family Judgment

That night, drowning in parenting self-doubt, I called my sister Priya in Bangalore.

“Kavya,” she said after hearing my story, “forget the gentle parenting criticism for a moment. Do you remember what Arjun was like before you started this respectful parenting approach?”

I thought back to when he was 2, before I learned gentle parenting techniques. The constant power struggles. Daily battles over everything. How he’d hit when frustrated because he didn’t have words for his emotions.

“He used to bite other kids when angry,” I admitted. “Now he comes and tells me, ‘Mama, I’m feeling mad because Didi took my toy.'”

“And that’s what your mother-in-law calls ‘too soft’?” Priya asked. “A 4-year-old who can identify and communicate emotions?”

Her words helped restore some parenting confidence. Maybe the gentle parenting criticism wasn’t seeing the full picture.

What I Learned About Gentle Parenting Criticism vs Reality

Over the next few days, determined to objectively evaluate my gentle parenting techniques despite ongoing gentle parenting criticism, I started documenting my interactions with Arjun.

When I used my respectful parenting approach:

• He cooperated more willingly (not immediately, but consistently)
• He came to me with problems instead of hiding them
• He showed empathy toward his younger sister
• His tantrums were shorter and less intense
• He actually listened to boundaries I set with empathy

When I tried traditional methods due to gentle parenting criticism:

• He complied out of fear, not understanding
• He became more aggressive with his sister
• He stopped sharing his feelings with me
• The power struggles increased tenfold

This evidence helped rebuild my parenting confidence despite the mother-in-law parenting advice pushing for different methods.

Also read: What everyone gets wrong about ‘gentle parenting’

Understanding the Science Behind Gentle Parenting Criticism

Facing constant gentle parenting criticism, I needed facts to support my respectful parenting approach. Here’s what research revealed:

Gentle parenting techniques aren’t permissive parenting. There’s a crucial difference:

• Permissive: “Okay, you don’t have to brush your teeth if you don’t want to.”
• Gentle: “I understand you don’t want to brush your teeth. It’s still time to do it. Would you like the blue toothbrush or red one?”

The traditional vs modern parenting debate often misses this distinction. Gentle parenting techniques actually represent what psychologists call the authoritative parenting style – high in both warmth and boundaries.

Research consistently shows that children raised with this respectful parenting approach develop:

• Better emotional intelligence
• Superior problem-solving skills
• More confidence and independence
• Lower rates of anxiety and depression

This evidence helped counter the gentle parenting criticism I was facing.

Handling Mother-in-Law Parenting Advice with Grace

Armed with renewed parenting confidence, I decided to address the gentle parenting criticism directly. I sat down with my mother-in-law for an honest conversation about traditional vs modern parenting.

“Mummy ji,” I started, “I understand your concerns about Arjun, and I value your mother-in-law parenting advice. You raised an amazing son. But I want to share why I use these gentle parenting techniques.”

I explained that my respectful parenting approach isn’t about letting kids do whatever they want. Gentle parenting techniques focus on:

• Setting clear, consistent boundaries
• Teaching emotional regulation instead of suppression
• Building trust so children share problems with us
• Preparing them for a world where emotional intelligence matters

“The traditional vs modern parenting approach isn’t about right versus wrong,” I said gently. “In your generation, children were seen and not heard. But Arjun’s world values communication, empathy, and emotional awareness. I’m not making him weak – I’m giving him different strengths.”

When Gentle Parenting Criticism Leads to Family Boundary Setting

This conversation taught me that family boundary setting doesn’t mean being disrespectful to elders. You can acknowledge mother-in-law parenting advice while maintaining your parenting confidence.

Here’s how I learned to handle gentle parenting criticism:

Acknowledge Without Agreeing

“I understand you’re concerned, and I appreciate that you care about Arjun’s development.”

Share Your Perspective

“These gentle parenting techniques have helped him become more emotionally aware and cooperative.”

Set Gentle Boundaries

“We’ve chosen this respectful parenting approach for our family, and we’d love your support.”

The key is maintaining parenting confidence while respecting family relationships, even when facing gentle parenting criticism.

Am I Too Soft With My Kids Gentle Parenting? The Real Answer

Six months after that initial gentle parenting criticism, here’s my honest answer to “Am I too soft with my kids gentle parenting approach?”:

I’m not ruining my kids – I’m raising them differently.

Arjun, now 5, demonstrates that gentle parenting techniques create strength, not weakness:

• He comes to me when he makes mistakes instead of hiding them
• He shows incredible empathy for others
• He can regulate his emotions (most of the time)
• He respects boundaries because he understands them
• He’s confident expressing his needs and feelings

Is he “soft” by some standards? Maybe. But he’s also emotionally intelligent, kind, and secure. In today’s world, these aren’t weaknesses – they’re superpowers.

Even my mother-in-law eventually said, “Kavya, I may not understand all your gentle parenting techniques, but I can see that Arjun is happy and confident. You must be doing something right.”

Overcoming Parenting Self-Doubt When Facing Gentle Parenting Criticism

If you’re dealing with gentle parenting criticism and wondering “Am I too soft with my kids gentle parenting?” here’s my advice:

Trust Your Evidence, Not the Criticism

Look at your child’s growth since starting gentle parenting techniques. Are they more confident? Communicative? Less aggressive? Trust what you observe.

Educate About Your Respectful Parenting Approach

Share resources about gentle parenting techniques with family members. Sometimes gentle parenting criticism comes from misunderstanding.

Build Your Support Network

Connect with other parents who share your respectful parenting approach. Online communities can provide parenting confidence when facing family gentle parenting criticism.

Practice Family Boundary Setting

It’s okay to tell family, “I appreciate your mother-in-law parenting advice, but we’ve chosen this approach for our family.”

Remember: Different Doesn’t Mean Wrong

The traditional vs modern parenting debate isn’t about superior methods – it’s about what works for your family in today’s world.

Real Talk: When Gentle Parenting Criticism Affects Your Daily Life

Let me be honest about handling gentle parenting criticism while maintaining gentle parenting techniques:

Some days, you’ll doubt yourself. Parenting self-doubt is normal, especially when facing gentle parenting criticism from people you love.

Your respectful parenting approach takes time. Yes, it’s faster to use fear-based methods, but gentle parenting techniques create long-term cooperation.

People will judge your choices. From mother-in-law parenting advice to stranger comments, everyone has opinions about your respectful parenting approach.

Learning never stops. I’m constantly adapting my gentle parenting techniques as my children grow and situations change.

The key is maintaining parenting confidence despite gentle parenting criticism.

The Bottom Line: Handling Gentle Parenting Criticism with Confidence

After months of questioning “Am I too soft with my kids gentle parenting?” and dealing with gentle parenting criticism, here’s what I know:

Gentle parenting techniques don’t create weak children – they create emotionally intelligent ones.

The traditional vs modern parenting debate will continue, and you’ll face mother-in-law parenting advice that conflicts with your respectful parenting approach. But your parenting confidence should come from observing your child’s growth, not from avoiding gentle parenting criticism.

When family members question your gentle parenting techniques, remember that you’re not just raising children – you’re raising future adults who will need emotional intelligence, empathy, and communication skills to thrive.

For Parents Facing Similar Gentle Parenting Criticism

If you’re constantly wondering “Am I too soft with my kids gentle parenting?” because of gentle parenting criticism from family, remember:

Your respectful parenting approach is preparing your children for tomorrow’s world, not yesterday’s. While traditional vs modern parenting methods both have value, you get to choose what works for your family.

Maintain your parenting confidence, practice gentle family boundary setting, and trust that your gentle parenting techniques are creating strong, emotionally healthy children.

A Little Note from Me:

I know this is a looong read – trust me, I see that scroll bar too! 

But here’s the thing – when I sat down to share this story, everything just poured out. My parenting journey, the doubts, the family drama, the midnight google searches… I wanted to cover every single aspect because I know how alone we can feel in these moments.

So grab your chai, get comfy, and know that every word comes from my real experience as a mom trying to figure it all out. Sometimes our stories are messy and long – just like parenting itself! ❤️

Have you faced gentle parenting criticism from family? How do you handle mother-in-law parenting advice that conflicts with your respectful parenting approach? Share your story below – let’s support each other through the traditional vs modern parenting challenges while building our parenting confidence together.

What resonated most with your experience of gentle parenting criticism? Are you still wondering “Am I too soft with my kids gentle parenting?” I’d love to hear how you’re navigating these challenges!

Looking for more support in handling gentle parenting criticism and building parenting confidence? Follow our Instagram for real mom stories about gentle parenting techniques and family boundary setting delivered straight to your inbox.

Your comments and shares do more than just support our blog—they uplift the amazing moms who share their stories here. Please scroll down to the end of the page to leave your thoughts, and use the buttons just below this line to share. Your support makes a big difference!